The Taliban prohibition on girls’ education shows the movement’s ultra-conservatives retain tight control of the Islamist group, and exposes a power struggle that puts at risk crucial aid for Afghanistan’s desperate population, experts say.
The ban has triggered international outrage and even left many in the Taliban movement baffled by the decision.
“The order was devastating,” a senior Taliban member told AFP. “The supreme leader himself interfered.”
All Taliban officials who spoke to AFP on the subject did so on condition of anonymity, due to the sensitivity of the topic.
Secondary schools for girls were ordered to shut last month, just hours after being reopened for the first time since the Taliban’s return to power in August.
The shocking U-turn came after a secret meeting of the group’s leadership in the city of Kandahar, the Taliban’s de facto power centre.
Officials have never justified the ban, apart from saying the education of girls must be according to “Islamic principles”.
But one senior Taliban official told AFP that Supreme Leader Hibatullah Akhundzada and some other senior figures were “ultra-conservative on this issue” and dominated the discussion.
Two groups — the urban and the ultra-conservatives — have emerged in the movement, he said.
“The ultra-conservatives have won this round,” he added, referring to a group of clerics including Chief Justice Abdul Hakim Sharai, Minister for Religious Affairs Noor Mohammad Saqeb and Minister for Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice Mohammad Khalid Hanafi.
– Reimposing Kandahar’s influence –
The clerics feel excluded from government decisions and voicing their opposition to girls’ education is one way to restore their influence, said Ashley Jackson, a London-based researcher who has worked extensively on Afghanistan.
She told AFP the “outsized influence of this out-of-touch minority” has prevented the country from moving ahead with something the vast majority of Afghans favour — including much of the leadership.
“It shows that Kandahar remains the centre of gravity for Taliban politics,” said International Crisis Group analyst Graeme Smith.
A senior Taliban member said the hardliners were trying to appease thousands of fighters who hail from the deeply conservative countryside.
“For them, even if a woman steps out of her home it is immoral. So, imagine what it means to educate her,” he said.
The Taliban member said Akhundzada was against “modern, secular education” as he associated it with life under former Western-backed presidents Hamid Karzai and Ashraf Ghani.
“That’s his worldview.”
The Taliban returned to power last year as US-led forces ended an occupation in place since an invasion ousted the hardliners in 2001.
In the 20 years between the Taliban’s two reigns, girls were allowed to go to school and women were able to seek employment in all sectors, though the country remained socially conservative.
Activist and Islamic scholar Tafsir Siyaposh noted girls in Afghanistan have always studied in single-sex classes and followed an Islamic curriculum, so the ban shows the Taliban just wanted to “oppress the rights of women by giving excuses”.
– Blow to foreign aid –
A Taliban source in Pakistan confirmed differences at the leadership level on the issue, but said the movement was in no danger of fragmenting.
“There is a debate on this issue … but we are trying to overcome our shortcomings,” he said.
Still, analysts say the ban was a blow to Taliban efforts to gain international recognition and to raise aid to address Afghanistan’s humanitarian crisis.
Jackson said neither Akhundzada nor those closest to him “fully understood or appreciated” the consequences of their edict for an international community that has linked official recognition to the group’s respect for women’s rights.
Even some senior Taliban officials agree.
“We are telling them (the ultra-conservatives) that running a country is different from running a madrassa,” said one Taliban official from Kandahar, using the term for an Islamic school.
“Everything was going smooth until this harsh order came. And it came from our leader so we have to follow it — but we are trying to change it,” he said.
The ban reduces the willingness of governments to cooperate with the Taliban said the ICG’s Smith.
“It raises the question of who exactly they should speak with inside the Taliban.”
Senate donates December salaries to victims of Kaduna airstrike
FDA approves gene-editing treatment for sickle cell patients
Everton trash Chelsea 2-0 at Goodison Park
Manchester City overcome Luton town 2-0
Tottenham thrash injury-hit Newcastle United 4-1
Arteta avoids controversy after Arsenal’s VAR woes
BBNaija’s Khloe laments loss of quality men after BBL
Senate donates N109m December salaries to Kaduna airstrike victims
Oladips: Many Nigerian musicians are depressed, Idowest opens up
Onana howlers, Ziyech heroics dent Man Utd UCL hopes
World’s oldest living triplets clock 93, get GWR recognition
Vincent Enyeama receives honorary doctorate from UNIUYO
Edo 2024: PDP will decide Shaibu’s fate – Obaseki
Kogi, Bayelsa, Imo voters set to elect new govt
Wheelbarrow pusher kills tax collector, self in Edo
Abia to increase minimum wage for workers
VIDEO: Thugs invade Osun APC secretariat
VIDEO: Strayed cow goes berserk inside NYSC orientation camp in Ogun
VIDEO: Are black cats bad luck?
VIDEO: Does COVID-19 only affect rich people?
VIDEO: Will I remain single if someone sweeps over my feet with a broom?
VIDEO: Gani Adams rallies Benin Republic monarchs for Sunday Igboho
FIDIO: Ǹjẹ́ Gbogbo Akitiyan Ìjọba Láti Mú Ẹ̀yìn Olóyè Sunday Ìgbòho Balẹ̀ Yìí Tọ́ Àbí Kò Tọ́?
VIDEO: Pastor Tunde Bakare declares National Movement
News17 hours ago
Ismaila Sodiq wins Remo Stars November Player of the Month award
News15 hours ago
Inflation: IMF urges CBN to raise interest rates
News21 hours ago
Nigerian publishers advocates revival of paper industry
News17 hours ago
Climate change: Nature-based solutions underfunded despite anual $7trn investment – UNDP
News17 hours ago
Pastor Adeboye reveals how, when he wishes to die
Politics17 hours ago
Egypt heads to poll amid Gaza unrest
News13 hours ago
TCN appeals for security support amidst rising vandalism
Entertainment13 hours ago
Oscar slap saved my marriage with Will Smith — Jada