Skip to content
Trending
Advertisement
Economy

Fashola faults Atiku’s fuel subsidy proposal, says plan unrealistic

Petrol pump as Nigeria’s daily fuel consumption falls by 600,000 litres

Former Minister of Works and Housing, Babatunde Fashola, has criticised the African Democratic Congress presidential candidate, Atiku Abubakar, over his promise to reinstate fuel subsidy if elected president in 2027, describing the proposal as unrealistic and difficult to sustain.

Fashola expressed doubts about the feasibility of the plan, citing Nigeria’s persistent crude oil production challenges, pipeline vandalism and insecurity.

He argued that the country had yet to maximise its existing oil production capacity, raising questions about the availability of sufficient crude oil to support local refineries and sustain the proposed subsidy arrangement.

The former Lagos State governor made the remarks on Tuesday while featuring on Channels Television’s Politics Today. He challenged Atiku to explain how his administration would guarantee adequate crude oil supply for domestic refineries while maintaining the subsidy policy.

Advertisement

“If we have refineries working, what is our current oil quota? Are we optimising it yet? No, because they are legacy issues, challenges with security people, vandalism. So where is this magic crude oil going to come from? People are entitled to ask,” he said.

He maintained that Atiku owed Nigerians a detailed explanation of how he intended to execute the proposal, insisting that voters needed sufficient information to determine whether the promise was achievable.

According to Fashola, making such a commitment without presenting a workable implementation strategy could create problems when confronted with the realities of governance.

“If he can explain, good, let the people choose. But without proof, it is like abracadabra. Because the reality that will come then is that he will say that, ‘I didn’t know that there was not enough crude oil.’ That was what happened,” he added.

Advertisement

Asked to assess the practicality of Atiku’s proposal, the former minister maintained that the policy was not viable, stressing that his criticism was directed at the proposal rather than the person behind it.

“The proposal is not realistic. I am looking at the proposal, not the personality.”

Fashola also raised questions about Atiku’s consistency on the subsidy debate, recalling that the former vice president had advocated the removal of fuel subsidy during the build-up to the 2023 presidential election.

He argued that the renewed commitment to restoring the policy required an explanation, particularly as the economic circumstances surrounding the previous election had not been adequately addressed.

Advertisement

“In this environment, it is very easy to throw promises at people. When the rubber hits the road, reality sets in. First question is, in 2023, didn’t he see through this when he was making the promise to remove the subsidy? And that goes to a question of credibility. Those who believe at face value that promise, he will come back and tell you that, ‘Oh, I changed my mind. I didn’t think through it,’” he said.

Beyond the economic implications, Fashola pointed out that bringing back fuel subsidy would require legislative intervention, arguing that the president could not independently reinstate the arrangement without addressing the existing legal framework.

He explained that lawmakers would have to amend the relevant legislation before the policy could be lawfully reintroduced. He also questioned whether members of the National Assembly would be willing to stake their political fortunes on supporting a return to subsidy payments.

“Subsidy is not just about, ‘I said it.’ It will come down to the real economy, and legislators will have to repeal a law to say subsidy is now lawful. How many legislators are ready to stake their election on going back to subsidy? Those are the real issues,” he said.

The former minister further challenged Atiku to identify the circumstances that had prompted his change of position since the 2023 election and explain how the financial demands of the proposed policy would be addressed.

While acknowledging that Nigerians were experiencing significant economic pressure, Fashola insisted that restoring subsidy without a sustainable funding arrangement would only create additional fiscal difficulties.

“Is it because people are impacted? It’s true. But what are you going to do differently? Where are you going to find the money to sustain what you are offering? It’s not sustainable,” he said.

Fashola, who served in the administration of former President Muhammadu Buhari, also drew attention to the financial consequences of the previous subsidy regime on state governments. He recalled that federal subsidy payments had significantly affected revenue available for distribution to states, leaving some governments struggling to meet their financial obligations.

He warned that a return to the previous arrangement could once again place state governments under financial pressure, potentially forcing some to obtain loans to meet workers’ salary obligations.

“I was in a government that was paying subsidy, and the states were not getting money. So are we going to go back to partial, near-zero returns, states borrowing money to pay salaries? Is that where you want us to go?” he asked.

Atiku, in August 2026, promised to reinstate fuel subsidy if elected president in the 2027 general election. However, his proposed approach differs from the previous system, as he advocated a temporary and independently audited subsidy framework linked to petroleum products refined locally rather than the import-dependent arrangement that operated in the past.

The former vice president argued that the policy would help bring down the cost of petrol, transportation and food, while providing relief to Nigerians struggling with rising living expenses.

President Bola Tinubu announced the removal of fuel subsidy during his inauguration on May 29, 2023, arguing that the arrangement had become too expensive for the government to maintain. The decision, alongside the subsequent unification of the foreign exchange market, contributed to higher petrol prices and increased living costs across the country.

Atiku has consistently criticised the Tinubu administration over the economic impact of its major policy reforms. However, Tinubu and the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) have rejected his proposed return to subsidy, arguing that such a move could undermine the government’s efforts to improve public finances and consolidate the gains of its reforms.

Meanwhile, Fashola has dismissed questions surrounding President Tinubu’s physical and mental capacity to continue leading the country, maintaining that he has observed no indication that the president is incapable of discharging his constitutional responsibilities.

He argued that although Tinubu is advanced in age, this should not automatically translate into doubts about his mental alertness or ability to govern. Fashola said his observations of the president suggested that he remained actively involved in official activities and continued to attend to government matters.

“Nothing suggests to me that he’s not fit for it. Yes, he’s older. That doesn’t mean his mental capacity is gone. He’s still giving directives. And when I see him, he’s working. He’s still reading, authorising, minuting on things,” Fashola said.

The former Lagos governor, who worked closely with Tinubu throughout his eight-year tenure as governor between 2007 and 2015, also reflected on the changes he had observed in the president over the years.

Comparing the Tinubu he encountered during their early working relationship in the 2000s with the current president, Fashola described him as a more experienced and mature individual, noting that both men had also grown older and accumulated considerable experience since their time in Lagos.

“Well, a much more mature one, certainly, without doubt. I am not the chief of staff he employed in 2002. That’s 39 years. I was 39 then. I’m 63 now. So we must give him that credit for the experience he has gained,” he said.

Fashola, however, acknowledged that Tinubu might not maintain the same demanding work schedule he was accustomed to earlier in his political career, particularly when it came to working late into the night.

Nevertheless, he expressed confidence in the president’s ability to continue handling the responsibilities of his office despite the possible adjustments to his daily routine.

“Maybe not keeping late nights that he used to do. I’m not sure. He can still run the engine,” he added.

Share
Keep reading

More gist like this

All Economy